Electra Files Lawsuit Against Trek; Cites Patent Infringement

Reported on Bicycle Retailer and Industry News on Tuesday, Electra is seeking damages against Trek for what they feel is a violation of their recently awarded patent. The Flat Foot Technology was a staple, and main selling point, of Electra bikes for several years while the patent was pending. With many imitators around the industry, it was only a matter of time before Electra began to protect their proprietary technology.

Comments

Uri - 01/26/11 - 9:24pm

Kind of strange that this is happening now, as a few companies have done “flat-foot” bikes, I know Giant has offered the Suede since at least ’08, and Trek had them going back to the Sole Ride in 2005.

KGr - 01/27/11 - 8:56am

Electra claims they invented it in 2003. The USPTO is very backlogged, and the patent may have gone through a tortuous process of rejections, appeals, and reexaminations. A patent pending isn’t a valid patent yet, but you copy it at your own risk.

dave - 01/27/11 - 7:10pm

Wow. You can patent long chainstays and really slack seat angle? Who knew?

KGr - 01/28/11 - 8:54am

You can’t patent “long chainstays and slack seat angles” for their own sake. However, if you show a previously unknown, unobvious (and no, hindsight does *not* count), useful application of them, you have a chance.

Most inventions out there involve using well-known materials and technologies in novel ways.

Varaxis - 01/29/11 - 12:44pm

Does that bike really have its drivetrain on the left side or is the image simply mirrored?

AnonymousChris - 01/29/11 - 3:52pm

It’s mirrored…

Realistically, Trek knew what they were doing when they used a pending patent in the bikes. They will probably end up paying Electra an undisclosed settlement, and pay Electra for future use of the patent. That payment is something they figured they would have to make day they made those cruisers in the first place, and is probably why the sources at Trek aren’t concerned about current stocks.

Androo - 01/30/11 - 3:01am

The complete lack of novelty in so many bicycle-related patents pains me a bit.

Post a comment:

Comment sections can be a beautiful source of knowledge, conversation and comedy. They can also get pretty ugly, which is why we've updated our Comments Policy. If your comment isn't showing up or suddenly disappears, you might want to check it out.