Review: Specialized Romin Road Saddle

specialized-romin-saddles-reveiw06

BIKERUMOR REVIEW: Over the last 12 years, I’ve put in some time on a number of different road saddles.  Some I liked, some I didn’t, but most had at least some good points.

Prior to the Romin, I was rotating through saddles and riding different review bikes with an alarming frequency, all the while talking to friends to see what they’re sitting on.  It seems virtually every cyclist that rides a Specialized saddle loves it…but no one had ridden the new Romin saddles yet.  One quick call to Specialized later and my butt’s on the Romin SL, a new saddle for 2010 that’s also supporting the butts of Team Saxobank (check out the interview from their training camp and first thoughts on this saddle).

First thoughts?  Best road saddle I’ve ever ridden.  Why?  Read on…

What’s In The Box?

specialized-romin-saddles-witb01specialized-romin-saddles-witb02

I’ve seen some Specialized saddles at retail that come with bar tape, so if you’re in the market, it’s worth double checking the seats for any bonus goodies stuck to the back of the packaging.  Basically, here’s what you get: Saddle, piece of plasticky packaging with information about Speciaized’s Body Geometry science.

The Romin and Romin SL Saddles come in three widths: 130mm, 143mm and 155mm.  Specialized dealers have (or should have) BG sit tests that you sit on to measure the width of your sit bones, then buy the appropriate saddle.  I went to Cycles de Oro to do it and, despite being 6’2″ and of normal proportions (ie. not super skinny, hips-like-a-10-year-old-boy), the gadget suggested I’d fit the narrowest 130mm saddle.  From what I can tell over the last few months, it didn’t lie.

specialized-romin-saddles-weight01

Claimed weight on Specialized’s website for the Romin SL 130: 204g.  Actual weight on our Park Tools scale: 204g. Nice.

Claimed weights for the other sizes are 208g (143mm) and 215g (155mm).  The Romin (non-SL) has claimed weights of 229g, 230g and 236g respectively.  The length on all models is 270mm.  Retail is $110 for the Romin, $150 for the Romin SL.

The only difference between the Romin and Romin SL are the rails.  The SL gets lighter hollow Ti rails and the regular version gets hollow chromoly rails.  Otherwise, they’re the same with a one-piece carbon-reinforced shell, “medium” rated padding and a water resistant Micromatrix cover.  They’re both available in black and white (tested), and the SL adds a white/red version that swaps the black shell for a red one.

specialized-romin-saddles-witb06specialized-romin-saddles-witb03

The Romin has a wide channel that runs almost the entire length of the shell.  The shell is a carbon reinforced plastic that’s tough enough for offroad use (which is good, because that’s where this saddle is headed next since we already have another new road saddle in to test…and Specialized’s marketing guy Nic says he’s running one on his mountain bike, too).

specialized-romin-saddles-witb05

What makes the Romin different from any other saddle Specialized makes is the kicked up tail.  They say it provides just enough of a bumper to push against, which is helpful on climbs and harder seated efforts.

How’s It Ride?

specialized-romin-saddles-reveiw07

Installed, the tail’s rise isn’t quite as dramatic.  Speaking of installation, because the seat isn’t flat, getting it level, as most fitters recommend, takes a little fine tuning as there’s really no good way to set a level on it as you’re making adjustments.  That said, from the very first ride, the Romin has been extremely comfortable, but even after several months of riding, I’m still tinkering with the angle now and then.

If you’re used to a perfectly flat saddle, the Romin may at first seem to be pushing you forward.  Even now, on some rides, I feel like I’m sliding forward a bit, but as you can see above, it’s sorta angled forward a bit anyway…which is why I’m still tweaking the settings occasionally.  It’s worth noting that the Micromatrix cover material does a good job of keeping you in place…it’s grippy enough to keep you from sliding around, but smooth enough to allow quick maneuvering.

specialized-romin-saddles-reveiw02

These orangish-brown marks on the sides appeared after the very first ride, which is odd because my shorts were clean and the chamois was not orange (or even tan) colored.  They haven’t gone away, either, despite hopes and wishes and absolutely no other efforts to clean it.

specialized-romin-saddles-reveiw05

From the pics above and below, you’ll notice that a) the nose of the saddle is a bit wider than some, and b) the center relief channel actually continues it’s groove all the way through the nose.  The width of the nose never felt awkward or intrusive, though.

specialized-romin-saddles-reveiw01

Here’s one of the best things about this saddle:  Never, not even once for a tiny bit, did I experience any numbness while on this saddle.  Even before I got it dialed in.  Even on long, 2.5+ hour rides in 40º or lower temps.  Even on hour-long trainer rides where I’m seated for the duration.  Perhaps that last bit is the most telling proof that the Body Geometry system works…on a trainer, it never feels like you’re putting the same force on your body as when outside, and thus is always seems like more pressure is on the sit bones (for me, anyway).  While it didn’t make trainer riding any more enjoyable (but this, this and this have), it was always comfortable.

specialized-romin-saddles-reveiw03specialized-romin-saddles-reveiw04

BIKERUMOR RATING:

The Specialized Romin SL is the first saddle I’ve ever put on my bike that’s just felt right from day one.  Yeah, I’m still tweaking the angle on it, but every ride’s been more enjoyable.  It’s amazing how an uncomfortable saddle can ruin even the best of rides, and finding one that works for you is probably one of the most important pieces of equipment you can upgrade with regards to your enjoyment of your bike.  And, as Team Saxobank illustrates, you don’t need to trade comfort for performance…the Romin delivers both in spades.  I’d highly recommend it.

bikerumor-thumbsup-4-5

Editor’s Note: Why not a full Five Thumbs up?  The color rub on the side really detracts from the cosmetics of the saddle, and it doesn’t appear to be caused by my shorts…we’ve run into this issue with other white saddles we’ve ridden.  If they could make it so it stays white, it’d be money.  For all practical purposes, though, this saddle is perfect.  If you’re a fan of perfectly flat seats, I’d recommend checking out one of Specialized’s other saddles just based on the Romin’s comfort and the anecdotal evidence I’ve heard from many, many other riders.

Comments

mr. peepers - 04/06/10 - 3:38pm

Wesley’s Bleech White may take off the “staining” you are experiencing on the sides. I had a white saddle that turned blue after riding on it in jeans and the Wesley’s did the trick. Try a small inconspicuous area firat to see how it reacts first.

Tyler (Editor) - 04/06/10 - 3:58pm

Thanks…I’ll check that stuff out.

Topmounter - 04/07/10 - 2:13pm

If you stay centered on the saddle, with the cut-out, you wouldn’t think “staining” would be an issue.

Piet van der Velde - 04/16/10 - 1:17pm

Hello Tyler.

Thank you for testing our saddle and writing up such a detailed and deep story of your test, Specialized really appreciates this.

In regards to the Romin keep your eyes open for more great stuff being launched at the upcoming Specialized product launches in June, there will be some great new additions to the Romin line.

In regards to the color staining on the saddle we would like to know some more details from your testing so we can improve our product and go for the “Full Five” in your next test.

Please tell us what brand and color shorts you where riding, and what where the overall weather conditions?
This will help us understand the situation and work on an improvement. I am asking you this specifically as we did a lot of testing on this issue but did not find excessive staining similar to yours.

Thank you and best regards

Piet van der Velde
Product Manager Specialized

[...] Review: Specialized Romin Road Saddle [...]

[...] for 2011 is the Romin Carbon. Based on the Romin saddle (which we reviewed here), it takes the same shape but lightens it up about 30g to 40g by using full carbon [...]

Julio - 09/20/10 - 10:59pm

It would be nice if Specialized could get the Romin saddle in the 150-175g category. For example, the Romin Gel 143 is too darn heavy at ~230g!

[...] Or look into the Specialized Romin saddles. Varying width and a channel the entire length of the saddle. http://www.bikerumor.com/2010/04/06/…n-road-saddle/ [...]

Patrick - 01/28/11 - 11:57am

I’ve been riding the romin saddle for a few months now and adore it as well, and i did get similar stains on mine. All you need is saddle soap, you can get it at equestrian stores or boot stores its for cowboy boots and horse saddles and makes my romin look brand new.

Al Hunter - 02/14/11 - 7:33pm

Hi from Christchurch, NZ. Home to Hayden Roulston!!
I’ve just had a bike fit and was given the Romin 143mm to trial.Was getting a little lower back pain.
Totally brilliant seat. Have since bought one and done 2000km+
Its on a 2009 S-Works Roubaix SL2. Great package.
The BG sit bone fit out was worthwhile. I went up from a 130 to the 143mm. Reduced hips dropping and rolling to low.
Ref the staining: I had a white Specialized Toupe prior to the Romin, and yep it stained a light brown in the same areas. Various bleaches, soaps etc only faded it, not removed in total.

Neil - 08/06/11 - 5:41pm

this is a saddle for those who like to sit and hammer and not much else…i had it on my sworks and couldn’t understand why my butt hurt so much, then i looked at the fizik site and learned that this is a seat for bulls and I’m a snake or chameleon…Specialized needs to focus on the customer and tell them what the saddle is suited for….if you like to come out the saddle a lot on climbs and move around, this saddle will kill you…that big curve in the back will become your nemesis…i stuck it on my cross bike so i won’t have to suffer

mrk - 02/29/12 - 6:57pm

I have had the Romin SL for the last 9 months & love it. make sure to get fitted in your local store. Great bit of kit for your bot.

phil - 08/06/12 - 4:15pm

nice review. I’ve been riding one of these for years. Just upgraded my bike and the included seat is not as good on long rides. Even tried a Fizik Aliante Versus which was worse!! Will be going back to my trusty Romin 143

Post a comment:

Comment sections can be a beautiful source of knowledge, conversation and comedy. They can also get pretty ugly, which is why we've updated our Comments Policy. If your comment isn't showing up or suddenly disappears, you might want to check it out.